South Park Studios Forums

There's a few "Who Would You Bring Back" threads, figured I'd give out a more specific one.

I say "no."

I didn't want him to die in the first place, but to bring him back wouldn't be... erm.

i actually really liked Pip. when he got squished i was just like the fck?!

A cameo in hell or something. Anything else would be weird and excessive.

Zazaban wrote:A cameo in hell or something.

I think that's a really good idea. It's the only way it would be acceptable in the canon, IMO. Pip was missing in action for half the series' life until that point, and it's safe to say they brought him back just to officially kill him. After all is said and done, there's no point in bringing him back.

I'd like to see him come back.

JVM wrote:There's a few "Who Would You Bring Back" threads, figured I'd give out a more specific one.

I'd say maybe!
But, probably in a cameo appearance! Honestly pip was kind of boring!

Hell yeah..Bring him back. I liked him.

i would like to seem him back... that's y i say yes

i remember MnT said something like everyone hates Pip including us.

I do not want to see Pip back in South Park. When he would show up, the show would just get boring and unfunny. I was rather glad when he stopped appearing, and do not like the idea of him coming back.

Pip should remain dead unless he returns as a ghost or a flashback.

zzyzx 1 wrote:[white]YES![/white]

As I said when my nick was "zzyzx 1,":

[white]YES![/white]

The reason: Even though M&T don't like the character, and it's their show, my opinion is that I have always liked Pip, and that episode he was in, "Great Expectations," got me to read the Dicken's book by the same name and I enjoyed Dicken's writing of that story. In public school we read various Dicken's books, and of course during the holidays we have all seen versions of Dicken's "A Christmas Carol." But I had never read "Great Expectations" before, and after seeing the SP episode I did read the book and I liked it. Therefore, I would like to see the return of Pip, even though the creators, M&T, killed him off with the intention of never bringing that character back to SP.