I think I'll give it an 8 or a 9 out of a ten.
pros: It was very funny and the scene with the Tourette's kid whose father left the family because he couldn't take it any more was pretty sad and touching. It wasn't overly preachy too and at least they used ideas of their own instead of making a parody of a film -or worse- a "political" episode.
Another good thing about this episode is the presentation of Eric's character:
I liked the fact that Cartman - for about the first time since season 4 - actually showed real emotion towards somebody other than himself. Admitting that he was in love with Patty and actually being - I think for the first time since his character change in season five, if not the first time ever since the beginning of the series - thankful to Kyle (who had already saved his neck at least two times and is waaaay to kind to Cartman ), was great. I always thought that there was some need to add at least a touch of humanity to his character. Also the things he said when he couldn't control his speech anymore reminded me of what a messed-up kid he is - just like in the Helen Keller-episode, where he saw all these pictures as he closed his eyes and the line "I'm not going to live as a goddamn minority" in "Ginger kids".
cons: The Cartman vs. Kyle formula is getting old and I think Stan needs to get much more screen time (I've given up Kenny a long time ago). Kyle's character used to be/or still is? a little more complex and could be used for other plotlines than his typical protagonist-to-the-Cartman-antagonist-role. I think I liked him most around seasons 3-5 and 7-9. In these seasons he could be both nice and a little brat, but wasn't as cruel as in seasons 1, 2 and 6 and didn't act like a goody-goody as in "Manbearpig". He became too much of a mouthpiece for M&T in season 10 and 11 for my taste. I still like him, though - he is pretty much the one who comes closest to an actual human being. Kenny is a prop, Stan doesn't seem to care anymore about anything at all (except for Kyle, maybe). I mean, he didn't even shout at the Rob Schneider-guy in "Stanley's cup", and Cartman is just vastly exaggerated. Don't get me wrong, I love all these characters.
Despite all this, I have to say I really enjoyed season 11 and this my third favourite episode right after "Fantastic easter special" and "Cartman Sucks".
PS: I don't get it why Craig is the one with the "I'd be sooo happy"-line. I mean, he has the tic of flipping off people himself. I've always considered Craig as sb who has tourette's himself. Actually, I'm a bit disappointed that they didn't mention it in the episode, as I expected them to after watching the trailers.
Probably M&T just forgot about his tic or his role is a parody on the fact that he has a tic himself, who knows?
Is this a sign that Craig maybe the 1 in 10?
Mr. Hat_DX27 wrote:Ok, I wasn’t so sure about that episode, but I have to admit, it picked up at the mid point. It looked like it was going to be some sort of lame reprise of It Hits the Fan, but it seems that, well, it wasn’t. It was just about sh*t, and some of the random obscenities made me lol. PISS OUT OF MY ASS! ME AND MY COUSIN TOUCH WIENERS! Etc etc etc. That part with the pedophiles also made me lol.
The formula of the episode was fairly typical. Cartman plotting something, Kyle tries to stop him, things don’t go out as planned, with some weird twist in the end, in this case, Kyle accidentally attracting a bunch of pedo weirdoes to the Date Line studio, and saving Cartman’s ass.
The start of the episode would have been 7/10, and the end would be 9/10, so I’ma give this thing an 8/10. Nothing too out of the ordinary, and progressively amusing. Let's hope the rest of the season can pick up!
I agree completely.
But I really hope this is the last Cartman-centered episode of the season, there has been so many already... I'm hoping for more Stan and Kenny!
"Now how about our gay couple, Stan and Kyle?"
I WET MY BED LAST NIGHT!
If I said tampon-dick to my teacher, I would be so happy!
That was so funny.
sunfl0wer wrote:But I really hope this is the last Cartman-centered episode of the season.
That's not going to happen by a long shot. There's still like 6 episodes left.
plk12345 wrote:how many times did they use the word "sh*t" in this?
Just watched it again. I counted 30 even.
The simplistic humour was what got to me most. Kids sitting in a circle all swearing and twitching at random times? I was laughing throughout the entire thing, and had to watch it 4 times to catch everything that was said. The guy who kept yelling 'PISS IN MY ASS' was absolutely hilarious, and every time he began speaking I was cracking up right away, just because I was expecting another nugget of an obscenity. Cartman's slurs were pretty funny, but the only real LOL was when he called Kyle's mom a kike [Which I didn't even laugh to at first, it just took a few seconds for the shock to set in then for the lulz to roll out. Best line of the show], which I thought was the worst thing said.
Craig felt repetitive, although his last line saved his role for me. Aww, all he wants to do is swear. I'm calling that slash art of him and that other tourettes kid is on deviantart right now.
[EDIT: holy lmao]
Best episode of the season as of now, a fully deserved 10/10. I have no idea who that Hansen person is, but I get the jist of him being one of those slimy assh*les who stitch up people, so I'm glad he got parody'd. Also; was that David Blaine killing himself because there were no brownies?
I hope that this standard is kept, I really do. If so, it's suiting up to be one of the best seasons so far.
BRMBug wrote::o I almost forgot! Did anyone else notice that the Super Adventure Club founder was on the toy store's signs?
YES! I was thinking of saying that, as you just did too. You beat me to it.
Cartmans the main reason why most people watch the show - episodes focused on Kyle or Stan are like the least funniest - episodes focuses are cartman are the funniest
anywayz - awesome episode again
one time my cousin and I touched wein, weeeeein, weeeeeiners
swellman7 wrote:Already, with the controversy...
Welp, there's been a follow up to that now:
http://tsa-usa.org/news/1007responseTSA ... ettes.html
They seem to be a little more neutral on the episode, but they aren't spewing irrational hate or anything, so it's not bad. Kinda like how at the beginning of season 11 it was assumed WATJJ was going to cause a lot of sh*t and yet it was well-received by the group in question.
Still like the episode, and I'm going to watch it again soon - it was really fantastic.
But I really hope this is the last Cartman-centered episode of the season.
I have disagree, Cartman eps are always really great.
However I am a little done with episodes that pit Cartman against Kyle.
But an episode like Scott Tenorman Must die is a good example of a Cartman episode that isn't Cartman vs Kyle archetype.
Jay C wrote:Best episode of the season as of now, a fully deserved 10/10. I have no idea who that Hansen person is, but I get the jist of him being one of those slimy assh*les who stitch up people, so I'm glad he got parody'd.
IMO you can't fully appreciate the episode or get the most humor out of it if you don't know about Chris Hansen and Dateline To Catch a predator because that's was the main focus of the second half of the episode and i thought it was hilarious. without that part it wouldn't have been as funny but now it deserves a 10/10
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests