It's good to finally see a new SP episode after all this time. Sure it's a Cartman episode, but hopefully it'll be funny and avoid outright reusing old plot elements.

You're supposed to hurt Al by giving him one number lower than the previous one, while you do the exact opposite for Randy.

Big Gay Al: 82 HURT
Randy Marsh: 109 HEAL

Big Gay Al: 84 HURT
Randy Marsh: 107 HEAL

Dawn of a new day.....

Big Gay Al: 86 HURT
Randy Marsh: 105 HEAL

Big Gay Al: 87 HURT
Randy Marsh: 104 HEAL

Good riddance to Gerald. Now let this be the Final Battle(TM).

Big Gay Al: 84 HURT
Randy Marsh: 107 HEAL

Big Gay Al: 83 HURT
Randy Marsh: 103 HEAL
Gerald Broflovski: 5

Big Gay Al: 77 HURT
Randy Marsh: 104 HEAL
Gerald Broflovski: 10

Big Gay Al: 78 HURT
Randy Marsh: 101 HEAL
Gerald Broflovski: 12

Just let Gerald die then instead of throwing your vote away. I know Randy can use more healing anyway.

Big Gay Al: 76 HURT
Randy Marsh: 101 HEAL
Gerald Broflovski: 14

Big Gay Al: 77 HURT
Randy Marsh: 100 HEAL
Gerald Broflovski: 14

Big Gay Al: 76 HURT
Randy Marsh: 101 HEAL
Gerald Broflovski: 14

Big Gay Al: 74 HURT
Randy Marsh: 102 HEAL
Gerald Broflovski: 15

Big Gay Al: 75 HURT
Randy Marsh: 102 HEAL
Gerald Broflovski: 14

Big Gay Al: 74
Randy Marsh: 100 HEAL
Gerald Broflovski: 17 HURT