This... is... THE BEST EPISODE OF THE LAST DECADE! Excellent in every detail. Brings back the old memories. I want to see part two of this plot. Just have to. :)

The voice Cartman used to have in the earliest seasons was way better than the new one. I also miss his old catchphrases like "You guys seriously!" or "Kick ass..." (said with his old voice).

For me all episodes from first three seasons are great. Yet, the best of them is 316 - Are yot there God? It's me, Jesus. The second come back of Jesus Christ and the truth about puberty were splendid.

I noticed that as the "Evil Cartman" was shot, he said "Screw you guys" which is what "Good Cartman" would say. You have to remember though that the evil Cartman is still CARTMAN, so his catchphrases would be known to his evil opposite. It really was the evil Cartman w...

My top 5 list of favorite characters: 5) Mr. Mackey - of course because of his way of speaking, m'kay? 4) Mr. Hat - a puppet or something more? He is my favorite unrealistic characters. 3) Mr. Garrison - who wouldn't love to have such a teacher in their years at elemental school... nobody? Hmm... ju...

Halloween themed episodes from seasons 1-3 are one of my favorites. I'd love to see a new one made in the spirit of those.

I have watched this episode like 7 times now and it's one of my favorite episodes of all time (...) Yes, I share the same point of view about this episode. I won't call it "the best episode ever", but it was one of the best from this half of thirteens' season. And you have to agree that '...

My favurite: 'You can say that again Mr. Garrison.' Just love it.

I'd love to see Mr. Hat's great comeback.

Anyone who would descend from the "Alternate Evil Reality" as shown in "Spookyfish."

He just reborn no matter how he manages to do that. Remember the episode "Cartman's Mom is Still a Dirty..."? He just pooped in. And his best reappearance was in "Red Sleigh Down." Boys asked him where was he all the time, just life if they've forgotten that he died a season earl...