I know this sounds pretty stupid, because it is all down to opinion, but I sometimes find it hard to see what people don't like about some epiosdes. Merry Christmas Charlie Manson? With all the stuff from Cartman's family and so many other great moments, I honestly have no idea why that would be con...

This thread has been done several times. Can't we just make one and sticky it?

Anyway, Pip and Not Without My Anus are the obvious choices. Those are the ones I didn't like at all. There are a few others that I found pretty weak but on the whole I've enjoyed all the rest.

Cartman also had Die Hippie Die...and Stan had already had Trapped In The Closet

...I still don't know what to think about this one. It was more of a "WTF" episode than anything. I wouldn't say I hated it, but then, I wouldn't say I particularly loved anything about it either.

That was in 906 - The Death Of Eric Cartman

I find it highly unlikely that this could be the breast cancer episode Matt mentioned. In last week's production blog, it was said that the team still had no ideas for the show, which suggests they were completely dry. If it is that so called episode, then they would have been aware before. I think...

I find it highly unlikely that this could be the breast cancer episode Matt mentioned. In last week's production blog, it was said that the team still had no ideas for the show, which suggests they were completely dry. If it is that so called episode, then they would have been aware before. Anyway, ...

I always thought they should do an episode called "At Home With the McCormacks" or something like that. Basically, its done similarly to "The Osbournes" but with Kenny's family instead.

this episode really was not that funny because there really was not a point to the show. I thought that the episode was going to have some big twist at the end like Willyzx actually talking to Kyle at the end of the episode; however, there were like in most episodes some highlights that I enjoyed, ...

Loved it. South Park is truly back to its best...season nine has really picked up in the second half. 913 was another great episode. Took a few minutes to get going but when it did, it was really funny. An appearance from Tweek also adds points.

As I posted in the other topic...

Another error is where all the boys go down the stairs into Cartman's basement. When the camera zooms in, Tweek is missing from the crowd.

It's a real story of the Bible, but it isn't spelled "Joe". I remember it has a very odd spelling, which I can't remember at the moment. I'll get back to you if I find out though.

Hmmm...this one sounds silly to me...

I hope I'm wrong

...which is weird because in this episode (512) it's pretty much implied the whole way through that Token lives in South Park.

In the first scene, Kenny's brother is standing on the left of the screen, yet he disappears when Stan's grandpa enters.