FORUM
Ask a Muslim (no wisecracks please)
Moderator: Big-Will
Re: Ask a Muslim (no wisecracks please)
There is a starving man in a canoe in the middle of the ocean. Give him a fishing net and he'll catch a fish. Give him the Bible or the Qu'ran and he'll starve to death while praying for a fish.
-
- Posts: 11192
- Joined: Fri Feb 13, 2004 8:36 pm
Re: Ask a Muslim (no wisecracks please)
> ShaneHaughey wrote :
> > Niels0827 wrote :
> > > thellama73 wrote :
> > > I've met many die hard Christians who have never read the Bible and it
> > > baffles me. How can they take a book as the guide for how to live if they
> > > don't know what it says?
> > > ___________________________________________________________
> > >
> > > Because if they read the Bible, they face the probability of becoming
> > > atheist. Many people are atheists BECAUSE they've read the Bible. Same
> > > thing with the Qu'ran.
> > >
> > > It'll open up people's eyes in a much different way than it was intended.
> > >
> > >
> >
> -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
> > >
> > >
> > > qharvard wrote:
> > > 2:191 is out of context and not exact. The [non-believers] part is not
> > > ___________________________________________________________
> > >
> > > It's not out of context. The non-believers are who the book was referring
> > > to. Throughout the Qu'ran, the sole and primary "antagonists" are
> > > 'non-believers' (i.e. non-Muslims, not just atheists).
> >
> >
> > Extremists don't read their chosen texts because extremists, by and large,
> attach
> > certain meanings to certain passages and don't wish to move beyond that. Moving
> > beyond that threatens their world-view.
>
> I have met some borderline extremists, and they do read their text. I'm talking about
> most religions here not just my own. That is why I don't like arguing over scripture,
> because people can twist it anyway they see fit. So why would I do the same thing,
> just to fit what I am saying?
Most extremists do not read their text- studies have shown this conclusively. And I too speak of all religions- extremist Christians and Catholics were the most likely to not read their holy text.

Terrorists/Extremists may read their holy text, but when they do, do they actually *read* the texts, or are they looking for validation of their own personal world view?
Re: Ask a Muslim (no wisecracks please)
> So if the scriptures and passages can be twisted and distorted in countless
> ways, why do you base your life around these scriptures? Something that can
> be interpreted in so many ways evidently has no meaning at all.
>
> There is a starving man in a canoe in the middle of the ocean. Give him a
> fishing net and he'll catch a fish. Give him the Bible or the Qu'ran and
> he'll starve to death while praying for a fish.
lol, why would you give a starving man a book? Wouldn't you instead rescue him, feed him, and try to return him to good health, help him find his way home?
You can give me a dollar bill. I can go to someone and make up a ton of sh*t about the dollar bill, what all the symbols mean, what the colors mean, what the letters mean. I can make up all kinds of stuff. Does that mean I can't go and spend that dollar? Ofcourse I can, just because I call a fly a truck doesn't make the fly a truck. It is still a fly.
I cannot even attempt to get someone to understand why I chose to believe in god, it is a very personal choice of mine. I make a lot of choices, and this is one of them.
Re: Ask a Muslim (no wisecracks please)
> Most extremists do not read their text- studies have shown this conclusively. And I
> too speak of all religions- extremist Christians and Catholics were the most likely
> to not read their holy text.

> Bible beyond a few passages that the head of that damnable congregation twisted to
> fulfill a personal agenda filled with his own personal hatred, then they wouldn't
> exist.
>
> Terrorists/Extremists may read their holy text, but when they do, do they actually
> *read* the texts, or are they looking for validation of their own personal world
> view?
Definitely the latter. It has to be the latter, because there is a ton of good vibes that they completely miss.
I feel what you are saying.
-
- Posts: 11192
- Joined: Fri Feb 13, 2004 8:36 pm
Re: Ask a Muslim (no wisecracks please)
> Niels0827 wrote :
> > So if the scriptures and passages can be twisted and distorted in countless
> > ways, why do you base your life around these scriptures? Something that can
> > be interpreted in so many ways evidently has no meaning at all.
> >
> > There is a starving man in a canoe in the middle of the ocean. Give him a
> > fishing net and he'll catch a fish. Give him the Bible or the Qu'ran and
> > he'll starve to death while praying for a fish.
>
> lol, why would you give a starving man a book? Wouldn't you instead rescue him, feed
> him, and try to return him to good health, help him find his way home?
>
> You can give me a dollar bill. I can go to someone and make up a ton of sh*t about
> the dollar bill, what all the symbols mean, what the colors mean, what the letters
> mean. I can make up all kinds of stuff. Does that mean I can't go and spend that
> dollar? Ofcourse I can, just because I call a fly a truck doesn't make the fly a
> truck. It is still a fly.
>
> I cannot even attempt to get someone to understand why I chose to believe in god, it
> is a very personal choice of mine. I make a lot of choices, and this is one of them.
It was not a literal interpretation. It is supposed to mean that it is better to help someone as people directly rather than use faith as a shield.
Re: Ask a Muslim (no wisecracks please)
> It was not a literal interpretation. It is supposed to mean that it is better to help
> someone as people directly rather than use faith as a shield.
Alright, got it.
Faith as a shield? Very complex thing, at least for me.
How about this. The bill of rights and constitution are always under a bombardment of people that want to manipulate it to serve their purpose. They lie about it, try to manipulate it so that it servers their purpose. It does not mean that those documents are any less of a very special text.
Even the freedom of speech. People are always trying to manipulate it to serve their purpose. Is hate speech allowed because we have the freedom of speech? Can we tell people to kill someone because, hey, we have the freedom of speech? I would say no.
-
- Posts: 34
- Joined: Thu Apr 29, 2010 2:36 am
Re: Ask a Muslim (no wisecracks please)
>Is hate speech allowed because we have the freedom of speech? Can we tell
> people to kill someone because, hey, we have the freedom of speech? I would say no.
I would say yes to both, but hey, I'm one of them wacky Libertarians you hear tell about.
Re: Ask a Muslim (no wisecracks please)
> qharvard wrote :
> >Is hate speech allowed because we have the freedom of speech? Can we tell
> > people to kill someone because, hey, we have the freedom of speech? I would say
> no.
>
> I would say yes to both, but hey, I'm one of them wacky Libertarians you hear tell
> about.
Have you watched Justice (with Michael Sandal) on ITunesU or on youtube? It gives a very good introduction into the basis of libertarianism, and a few other isms as well. It is quite good.
Re: Ask a Muslim (no wisecracks please)
I cannot pretend to be a very smart person, nor am I trying to, but I can say that sometimes it is hard not to go with my first thought, reaction, or perception.
Often I have to control myself enough to take a risk and ask a few questions in order to begin to understand. It is easier to just base all of my decisions on gut reactions, but that doesn't always end in amiable results. I hope that others can share this experience.
Also, every time I get called "token" I die a little inside. THANKS!
-
- Posts: 9593
- Joined: Thu Apr 17, 2003 4:32 am
Re: Ask a Muslim (no wisecracks please)
Triple, you say that religion makes starting wars easier, to that I say, not everyone who believes in supernatural things is going to blindly follow some leader who invokes the name of their God. Some people are followers some people think for themselves. That is true of both both religious and non religious people. Even if there was no religion or belief in the supernatural, there would still be assh*les who would want more power, and they would still think of a way to get people to go to war for them.

Re: Ask a Muslim (no wisecracks please)
http://current.com/1ep8g4c
Re: Ask a Muslim (no wisecracks please)
> Qharvard, I was wondering if you are South Park fan, if so, how many years
> have you been watching the show, and are you planning on staying at the
> board and posting in other threads and getting to know the rest of us
> regular posters.
>
>
> Triple, you say that religion makes starting wars easier, to that I say,
> not everyone who believes in supernatural things is going to blindly follow
> some leader who invokes the name of their God. Some people are followers
> some people think for themselves. That is true of both both religious and
> non religious people. Even if there was no religion or belief in the
> supernatural, there would still be assh*les who would want more power, and
> they would still think of a way to get people to go to war for them.
I am a South Park fan. I have been watching for years. Unfortunately I don't have the bandwidth to stick around for long. We will see what happens.
Peace.
-
- Posts: 6124
- Joined: Mon Jan 31, 2005 5:24 am
Re: Ask a Muslim (no wisecracks please)
> Triple, you say that religion makes starting wars easier, to that I say,
> not everyone who believes in supernatural things is going to blindly follow
> some leader who invokes the name of their God. Some people are followers
> some people think for themselves. That is true of both both religious and
> non religious people. Even if there was no religion or belief in the
> supernatural, there would still be assh*les who would want more power, and
> they would still think of a way to get people to go to war for them.
I would agree. And I wish that was the case even more often than it is.
Back to Islam.
Others have touched on this, but the extremist element of this religion does the same thing those Westboro crackpots do; they quote mine their religious texts for any passages that reinforce the radical views they already have. And because it's the (insert holy book here), those quotes carry all the authority they've assigned that book.
This is authority that certainly isn't deserved given the history of these texts. They were compiled generations after the main protagonists lived from disparate sources. They've been translated umpteen times. They've been edited by kings and religious heads to suit their need. To accept any of them as the literal word of god takes the willful suppression of logic, reason and good old common sense.
Here's my interpretation of these 'sacred' texts: A bunch of religious leaders desperate to stay in power need something to placate the peons, so they cobble together a bunch of century-old anecdotes about their god, throw in some otherwise secular life lessons in a religious context and slap 'em into a book. That book gets distributed and edited & translated by every society it encounters for a thousand years or six. Then a person picks it up, quote mines something they like, turns around and says, "GOD HATES FAGS!!!" or blows up an embassy?
Gimme a break.
You read it! You can't unread it!
-
- Posts: 9593
- Joined: Thu Apr 17, 2003 4:32 am
Re: Ask a Muslim (no wisecracks please)
That what it takes to make someone into a violent extremist. It isn't a belief in the supernatural or in life after death. It is thinking for whatever reason you and your little clique of assh*les are so much better than everyone else, and that you have the right to push everyone else around, and treat them like they are ignorant or evil, and that it is ok to dehumanize them. It is those attitudes that lead to people bombing others, or picketing funerals with their "God hates Fags" signs. Think about that.

Re: Ask a Muslim (no wisecracks please)
So what I want to know is what is your oppinion on other religions getting mocked by South Park and do you believe that it's okay to mock other religions, but not the Islam religion?
The reason I ask because this is how it comes across by Comedy Central when they allow jokes about other religions, but as soon as Islam gets insulted it's all censor bars and bleeps? (seriously the Jews are always getting the mickey taken out of them on South Park and every other religion has been insulted by South Park too).
BTW I mean no offence with this post and appologies if I do so unintentionally as I believe it should either be okay to mock every religion or not okay to mock every religion (which I think was the theme of episode 200 and 201 where the celebs and the gingers wanted whatever it was making Muhammed un-mockable).
Return to “Off Topic Discussion”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests