Re: Do You Want to See Pip Back?
Posted: Sat Feb 25, 2017 12:28 am
But-but it even says they're the same person ●︿●Big-Will wrote:It's also pointed out there that she had different sets of parents throughout the show's run, so this is not a mere case of renaming. Thus, Marcy and Heidi are two unique, different girls. But to avoid confusion, they're put together on the same page. Also, Marcy didn't have a last name when she appeared in Season 4, and nor did her parents. "Turner" cannot be applied to them retroactively.Bunny Style wrote:But it even confirms Marcy was renamed to Heidi! T_TBig-Will wrote:Heidi Turner, Karen McCormick, and Marcy all had the same character design, doesn't mean they were ever the same person.
http://wiki.southpark.cc.com/wiki/Heidi_TurnerDunno what Trey was thinking there, since they appeared one year apart, with vastly different personalities. At least Heidi appeared five years after Marcy did. Still, Lorraine and Lisa are... two unique, different girls. But to avoid confusion, they're put together on the same page.Bunny Style wrote:The same thing happened with Lisa Berger too!!! D:
But- but Pip actually had his own episode, made many appearances and had been a secondary character even before South Park began!Big-Will wrote:Would you accept Pip if he came back under a different name? Wouldn't that take away from his uniqueness?
Probably because we all know deep inside Chef will probably return one day. He has the potential of being Darth Chef and even appeared in the South Park Stick of Truth game.mario88 wrote:just out of sheer curiosity, why some of you are so interested in seeing Pip agin? I mean, maybe i missed it, but i don't see such a thread for a much more relevant character like Chef was.
maybe even miss Crabtree at this point would deserve a "please raise from the dead" thread.
I even liked Choksondik too! xD