FORUM
*1114: The List*
Moderator: Big-Will
-
- Posts: 1144
- Joined: Thu Jul 05, 2007 4:30 am
Re: *1114: The List*
9/10 very good ep certainly better than guitar queer-o, this is an A and it was funny ''we now know that girls dont have ballz'' lol that was so funny when butters kicked her, very funny episode and a well done to a season ender.

Re: *1114: The List*
List:
Clyde
Token
Stan
Bradley
Jason
Leroy
Kenny
Tweek
Kevin
Jimmy
Butters
Craig
Timmy
Francis
Cartman
Kyle
--------
Later Bebe discusses the list:
"To move Clyde meant Craig had to be moved to #12. Which moved Jimmy down and moved Jason up."
So, wouldn't that make the original list:
1.Craig
2.Token
3.Stan
4.Bradley
5.Jimmy
6.Leroy
7.Kenny
8.Tweek
9.Kevin
10.Jason
11.Butters
12.Clyde
13.Timmy
14.Francis
15.Cartman
16.Kyle
As Bebe also said, Kyle was a casultie. Though they never said Kyle moved up or down, it can be assumed Stan/Wendy glanced at this list and was possibly first, making Craig the ugliest, as Cartman suggested earlier.
Clyde
Token
Stan
Bradley
Jason
Leroy
Kenny
Tweek
Kevin
Jimmy
Butters
Craig
Timmy
Francis
Cartman
Kyle
--------
Later Bebe discusses the list:
"To move Clyde meant Craig had to be moved to #12. Which moved Jimmy down and moved Jason up."
So, wouldn't that make the original list:
1.Craig
2.Token
3.Stan
4.Bradley
5.Jimmy
6.Leroy
7.Kenny
8.Tweek
9.Kevin
10.Jason
11.Butters
12.Clyde
13.Timmy
14.Francis
15.Cartman
16.Kyle
As Bebe also said, Kyle was a casultie. Though they never said Kyle moved up or down, it can be assumed Stan/Wendy glanced at this list and was possibly first, making Craig the ugliest, as Cartman suggested earlier.
-
- Posts: 69
- Joined: Sun Mar 04, 2007 3:12 pm
Re: *1114: The List*
7.7/10
The investigation seems used up a little bit too much time and Kyle being a bit too desperate. Butters slightly out of character for being a real bad brat -- if I am Kyle I will beat Butters up.
Wendy made a good return while Kenny seems to have more airtime because he has to die
A nice try to make an early-style episode, though apart from Kenny's death and the Stan/Wendy reconciliation, this episode still misses a bit from a good season finale.
P.S. I don't expect more Kenny, I wonder how Wendy and Butters' roles will be played in season 12. Their changes in this season will affect later plot bases.
The investigation seems used up a little bit too much time and Kyle being a bit too desperate. Butters slightly out of character for being a real bad brat -- if I am Kyle I will beat Butters up.
Wendy made a good return while Kenny seems to have more airtime because he has to die

A nice try to make an early-style episode, though apart from Kenny's death and the Stan/Wendy reconciliation, this episode still misses a bit from a good season finale.
P.S. I don't expect more Kenny, I wonder how Wendy and Butters' roles will be played in season 12. Their changes in this season will affect later plot bases.
A Chinese Butters wearing a Bavarian shirt
-
- Posts: 12
- Joined: Thu Oct 25, 2007 10:54 pm
Re: *1114: The List*
eatmydeaduterus wrote:Stan's puke looked better than ever
I cant belive how happy I was to see Stan barf on Wendy again.
Re: *1114: The List*
Butters slightly out of character for being a real bad brat -- if I am Kyle I will beat Butters up.
Yeah Butters was a little enoying in the episode running around with his t shirt and when he called Kyle pizza face,maybe he was just happy to be given a break for a change.I noticed Kyle was going to burn the school down during the night when there was no one in the building.
Kyle: Why? How could you do this? There are people starving in Alabama and you give Cartman a million dollars?
Cartman: Line? Lines! I HATE LINES!!!
Cartman: Line? Lines! I HATE LINES!!!
Re: *1114: The List*
Incredibly funny! Thumbs up, keep it up for season 12!
*Sigh*
How many times do we have to get through this?
You're black, you can play bass.
How many times do we have to get through this?
You're black, you can play bass.
Re: *1114: The List*
CrotchCapers wrote:eatmydeaduterus wrote:Stan's puke looked better than ever
I cant belive how happy I was to see Stan barf on Wendy again.
Yup. it's love
And don't mind Butters being out of character, he gets screwed over almost every episode. Remember Marjorine?
Re: *1114: The List*
Agreeing with never being so happy to see Stan puking. The puke has even udgraded from solid to liquid form.
I'd say there are two things that would've made this episode awesome, since they seemed to be taking a trip down memory lane:
1. "Oh my God, they killed Kenny!"/"You bastards!" line. I was like ZOMG THEYRE GONNA SAY IT!!!1!!!11 But they didn't. Ah, well.
2. "See, I've learned something today..."
I'd say there are two things that would've made this episode awesome, since they seemed to be taking a trip down memory lane:
1. "Oh my God, they killed Kenny!"/"You bastards!" line. I was like ZOMG THEYRE GONNA SAY IT!!!1!!!11 But they didn't. Ah, well.
2. "See, I've learned something today..."

"...But then, the lesson of Gore's Nobel Prize is that to talk big but do nothing of substance is what society rewards." -TMQ, ESPN Page 2
Re: *1114: The List*
did anyone else think Abe Lincoln was a child molester like in the "Child Abduction" episode?
-
- Posts: 149
- Joined: Thu Oct 04, 2007 2:53 am
Re: *1114: The List*
Are people seriously angry at Butters for this episode?
It didn't seem out of character that much to me.
I mean the kid was excited.
Not coming last in a looks contest, and not getting grounded.
Hell I'd be pretty excited too.
It didn't seem out of character that much to me.
I mean the kid was excited.
Not coming last in a looks contest, and not getting grounded.
Hell I'd be pretty excited too.
Drink Up Me Hearties, YoHo~
Re: *1114: The List*
ClownCarOnFire wrote:Are people seriously angry at Butters for this episode?
It didn't seem out of character that much to me.
I mean the kid was excited.
Not coming last in a looks contest, and not getting grounded.
Hell I'd be pretty excited too.
If you want the grim, depressing version of Butter's behavior, watch the movie Welcome to the Dollhouse. The second you stop feeling like you're on the bottom of the peckinig order, you start picking on those who are.
Zubby
-
- Posts: 149
- Joined: Thu Oct 04, 2007 2:53 am
Re: *1114: The List*
Zubby wrote:ClownCarOnFire wrote:Are people seriously angry at Butters for this episode?
It didn't seem out of character that much to me.
I mean the kid was excited.
Not coming last in a looks contest, and not getting grounded.
Hell I'd be pretty excited too.
If you want the grim, depressing version of Butter's behavior, watch the movie Welcome to the Dollhouse. The second you stop feeling like you're on the bottom of the peckinig order, you start picking on those who are.
Exactly. It's pretty normal actually.
I thought it was funny, hell even my mom did.
Butters was so cute lol.
Drink Up Me Hearties, YoHo~
Re: *1114: The List*
Best ep of Season 11 IMO. Good, and unexpected Kenny death, and the barf gag still makes me laugh. And Butters was so horribly cute.

Return to “Spoilers/New Episode Discussion”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests