*1405: 200* Post-Air Discussion

[HAcoreRD]

So many memories flooded back. Episode seemed all over the place, but it's a good memory jogging episode. Though i hate 2 parters.

I'm sure we'll get screwed and not find who Eric's dad is, though i bet it's 1 of 2 characters who VANISHED from South Park.

Either Mephisto or that little thing that followed him.


PS: where's Issac Hayes... or Darth Chef?

[Iamdnjc]

IS cartmans father Mohammad?

[Diabeteth]

IS cartmans father Mohammad?

Mohammad wasn't in the room back in Cartman's Mom is Still a Dirty Slut.

[TurdinPunchBowl]

why are they wrecking their previous masterpieces?

[tribefan]

I'm calling 4 parter they're gonna be such dicks they will wait till the Fall to show us who Cartman's father is.

[triplemultiplex]

Woah, the site took a major dump on me. Finally got on half hour after airing.

I was right on with my guess about tons of little tidbits for the longtime fan.

Mr. Hat
Ms. Lopez
Sally Struthers
Everyone was there, even Mr. Hat!
Mecha Streisand 2.0 was killer. Completely over-the-top and very Iron Man-esque.

Tons of great comedy; just loved it. Tom Cruise and his fudge packing and many closets. The Super Best Friends title sequence, complete with a 2001 copyright at the bottom.

The obvious question regarding the end; do we get a part 2 or something or are they going to just leave us dangling. I think it'd be funnier if they didn't do a part 2 and just left us hanging with those cliff hangers.

If this episode is to be believed, we can throw out the Cartman's mom is a hermaphrodite canon and are free to investigate the identity of Cartman's father.

Total win this week. Happy 200, South Park!

[IKyman]

What an intriguing episode/special. It was nice to see Tom Cruise telling Stan that he will sue him by calling him names. That had me lol'd.

My thoughts on who is indeed Eric Cartman's father--the real father.

[XxSiriusxX]

I can honestly say, this was my FAVORITE episode ive ever seen, it touched on alot of my favorite SP moments and gave them new life, Oh god Mitch Connor, jennifer lopez I missed you! lol

THANK YOU SOUTHPARK CREATORS! I cant wait for part 2

[hedden93]

IS cartmans father Mohammad?

Mohammad wasn't in the room back in Cartman's Mom is Still a Dirty Slut.

lol Maybe he was but he was just censored.

[XxSiriusxX]

I thought Cartmans dad was a mixture of all of the mens sperm into her at once lol

[jmlunders]

Love the remake of the Mecha-Streisand theme. Let's hope they give some closure before the mid-season break.

[Iamdnjc]

IS cartmans father Mohammad?

Mohammad wasn't in the room back in Cartman's Mom is Still a Dirty Slut.

No he wasn't but he is a "god" maybe he was there in spirit ... jesus never met mary

[Biscuits]

NO WAY, they can't just say Cartman's mom isn't a hermaphrodite now! I'm so pissed.
I didn't really care about the rest of episode because now I want to know who his father is.
My guess is they're not going to tell us, but it would be funny if it was Kyle's dad.

[Metal_Meatwad]

(Ignore my let's discuss it here and things like that, I know it's obvious we discuss it here. I just copied my message from another forum I go too)

If your "hella" confused over Tonight's episode of South Park Like the rest of us. Lets discuss it here! I mean they ended it abruptly, and didn't even say To Be Continued Like the Rest of the 2 or 3 part episodes. A "To Be Continued" would have been nice."This episode was a tiny bit everywhere, seemed a tad unfocused, and where was no Mr. Hankey or Towelie, and Kenny didn't die? But overall I LOVED IT! GRADE: A+VOICE YOUR OPINIONS!

Even though it had some problems I did love this episode, and is one of my favorites in a long time.
Also,
Chef is so... Eric's Father... His character is not dead in a way. I mean he is Darth Chef now.... "Cartman [CHHH] I am your father!" I feel like they are setting us up for this.[CHHH]

Or it might be Gerald Brovloski. They might have hidden it because Cartman would go insane finding out he is Jewish and related to Kyle. (But they won't go technical if they do this since the mother has to be Jewish in order for her child to be Jewish, it doesn't matter about the father.)
I am calling Next Week's Episode is either a Terrance and Phillip or Queef Sisters' Episode. Followed by the Season Finale being the Continuation to this episode!

[IKyman]

I have a bad feeling that Gerald is Cartman's father.