FORUM
Kyle Dies - The Final Chapter
Moderator: Big-Will
-
- Posts: 2226
- Joined: Wed Apr 19, 2006 10:06 pm
Well, since people are still reading this, I've gone back and made the corrections I had come up with to this version of it as well. I've corrected the grammar on the chapters where I wasn't able to get a beta-reader, and I made sure the doctor's name is spelled correctly.
And thanks for the reviews.
And thanks for the reviews.
I found this story to be a good read. In particular I liked how you made those Goth kids actually care for their own, essentially humanizing them so that they're more than mere sterotypes. The main boys were all well-done too. My only tiny gripe is that I had to read the reference post to figure out who Carl and Isaac were, but that's no biggie really. So good job. 


Every step back a step foward.
Every failure an extra opportunity for success.
Every day of defeat a victory!
-
- Posts: 13
- Joined: Sat Feb 03, 2007 3:11 pm
I read it again, paying closer attention to it this time. Generally an impressive fanfic. I can write stories, but not fan fiction because I can't adapt to styles very well, or at least not as well as this. It truly deserves a solid 10/10.
Not to sound too show-offy with music theory, but you can't strum chords on a bass guitar. You should change "chords" to "notes". I know, it's a very minor problem that I'm picking at, but I have OCD so I tend to magnify little things like this.
Not to sound too show-offy with music theory, but you can't strum chords on a bass guitar. You should change "chords" to "notes". I know, it's a very minor problem that I'm picking at, but I have OCD so I tend to magnify little things like this.

As enjoyable as abuse.
-
- Posts: 2226
- Joined: Wed Apr 19, 2006 10:06 pm
-
- Posts: 38
- Joined: Tue Mar 27, 2007 9:04 pm
Um, actually, you can strum chords on the bass. It's just not too common. It's been done by Cannibal Corpse before. The late Cliff Burton of Metallica did it too. And I have definitely heard Suffocation's bassist playing chords in one of their songs.
In fact, here's a section of a bass tab for Suffocation's "Tomes of Acrimony" to prove it.
And have I reviewed this one yet? Well, in case I haven't, I really like this one a lot. This seems to have been your first novelized fic, and you pulled it off excellently. 10/10.
In fact, here's a section of a bass tab for Suffocation's "Tomes of Acrimony" to prove it.
Code: Select all
1.
W Q H E E W Q H S E.
||-----------|-------------|----------|----------------||
||o----------|-9-----------|----------|-9-------------o||
||o----------|-7-----------|----------|-7-------------o||
||--0--------|-0-------0-0-|-0--------|-0-------0-0----||
2.
Q H Q
|--------------|
|-9------------|
|-7------------|
|-0-------0----|
And have I reviewed this one yet? Well, in case I haven't, I really like this one a lot. This seems to have been your first novelized fic, and you pulled it off excellently. 10/10.
I knew Metallica did it, but there aren't enough good-sounding bass chords to construct the entire "I'm A Jew" song, especially without any overdrive (and I don't know why the hell someone would use overdrive to play a song like "I'm A Jew") and as you said, it's very uncommon. Almost as uncommon as putting tape on a harmonica and playing it that way (LOL, even though I'm guilty for doing it for fun).

As enjoyable as abuse.
It is awsome
Your fanfic is so great. It is the first fanfic I ever read. I am also glad there are some Kyle fans out there other than me. I give your fanfic a 10 out of 10. And for a idea for another fan fic here is a idia. Cartman finds out that somehow he is Jewish. I dont care if you use is(infact I would like you to make a fanfic of it because I cant wright fanfics).
Kenny914
Kenny914
My favorite characters of South Park are, Stan,Kyle,Wendy,Jesus,Jimbo,Terrace,Phillip,
Ned,and Kenny.[img] http://www.stansdad.com/data/userbars/userbar_Blue.png[/img]
Ned,and Kenny.[img] http://www.stansdad.com/data/userbars/userbar_Blue.png[/img]
-
- Posts: 2226
- Joined: Wed Apr 19, 2006 10:06 pm
crap
Damit why cant I ever come up with original ideas.
My favorite characters of South Park are, Stan,Kyle,Wendy,Jesus,Jimbo,Terrace,Phillip,
Ned,and Kenny.[img] http://www.stansdad.com/data/userbars/userbar_Blue.png[/img]
Ned,and Kenny.[img] http://www.stansdad.com/data/userbars/userbar_Blue.png[/img]
-
- Posts: 1144
- Joined: Thu Jul 05, 2007 4:30 am
-
- Posts: 2226
- Joined: Wed Apr 19, 2006 10:06 pm
-
- Posts: 3
- Joined: Fri Jul 20, 2007 3:06 pm
Return to “FanFics and Episode Ideas”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 1 guest