Garrison was best as...

[AngusMcTavish]

Pretty basic, really. Just tell us which version of Garrison you liked better out of all his/her personae.

Personally, I preferred the original "Mr. Hat" style, but his time with Mr. Slave had its funny moments, too.

[Kaixx]

Mr. Hat Garrison.

I miss Mr. Hat. ;-;

[swellman7]

I liked him best as a woman that likes men. So basically from season 9 to 11.

[sunfl0wer]

I'd say I liked him best as man-gay! but then again, I miss Mr. Hat!

[love*metal]

Werido Garrison, when he had Mr Hat. He was awsome back then.

[BRMBug]

Is there an "other"?

Actually, the first two.

[triplemultiplex]

All of the best Garrison stories were back in season 4. His transition from a gay-bashing closeted homo to a demented, openly gay man was one of the best plotlines in the history of South Park. But he's been going down hill ever since Death Camp of Tolerance. I enjoyed the Lemmiwinks plot of that episode a lot, but Mr. Slave was a step down from Mr. Hat. And the sex change was a major step down from Mr. Slave. So far, the lesbian development seems like a side-ways step to me. Just another way to get Garrison into some 'gross out' comedy scenes.

[AngusMcTavish]

^ I agree. Anyone else think the whole "scissor" thing was just overly done?

[Thunderhorse]

Mr. Hat Garrison by far. He was at his best back then. Mr. Slave Garrison was also kinda funny, but it pales in comparrison to Mr. Hat Garrison. Woman Garrison is lousy, overused, and an insult to one of my favorite characters from the early days. "D-Yikes" was pretty funny, though.

[203177]

i would have to say the mr garrison was best with mr hat, but now he's just too weird as a lesbien.