Who do you like better, Mr or Ms. Garrison?

[Infusions]

They were both an excuse to be able to use sex jokes or sex plots.

So I don't think it really mattered that much to me.

Although, I do miss it when he would shout out at the students in such rage and be calm the next second. So if anything, I like it more when Garrison was dealing with school plots rather than sex plots.

"Go God Go" was a nice blend of the two and extremely well done, though. +15 to that.

[sp150]

Mr. Garrison, mostly because as Mr. Garrison he showed more personality, although it might help that (s)he has had few episodes with him/her as a central character not involving him/her in a relationship since the "change".

[stupidrandy]

Garrison is funny, no matter what sex.

[KYLEZ#1FAN]

Mister. Garrison was much funnier when he/she had balls in my opinion. And the whole lesbian thing is just weird to me. In Follow That Egg, he/she was almost homophobic, what changed his/her mind?

Also, I miss Mr. Hat. M&T should bring him back somehow... he was a good character, even if he was a puppet.

[ClownCarOnFire]

I like both. I mean, he didn't really change to me.
Now he just has a mutilated penis.

[-K3NNY-]

Mr Garrison is better than Mrs Garrison

[WhatevaIWaunt]

Definitely Mr. Garrison. His (her) personality completely disappeared when he got the sex change, now, all she is is a loud-mouthed jerk. Mr. Garrison was a loud-mouthed jerk, especially after he came out, as he was flaunting his openess (trust him to wreck people's impression of gays) but that was only one of many hilarious and amazing character traits. Mrs Garrison is just annoying, but Mr. Garrison was one of my favorite characters.

[AngusMcTavish]

He was better as Mr. G, especially when he had Mr. Hat. Some Mr. Slave moments were hilarious, and shortly into the Mrs. era had some laughable lines, but with "D-Yikes!" it all went downhill. I found her "scissor" obsession to be tiresome, personally.

And I could not watch those "operation" scenes from 901 without getting queasy.

You know, I think my poll on this is still around here somewhere...

Ah, yes, HERE it is!

[Pip Tweek]

I liked the way Mr. Garrison evolved throughout the series, but episode 901 effectively destroyed him as a character.

Telling Mr. Slave to "just stop being gay" after all he'd been through in coming to accept himself seemed really unlikely for Garrison at that point in the series. It's like this woman thing came out of nowhere; he was ready to kill the Queer Eye guys for promoting the "metrosexual" fad that he perceived as a threat to his identity. And now he's a woman that is attracted to women. Is Garrison really that unstable?

Granted he's always been prone to going over the top, but in spite of his psychotic fits he appeared to have a reasonable outlook on the world. Now he's become a parody of himself.

Some things get better with age. Mr. Garrison isn't one of them.

[GUITARQUEER-O]

Bzzzt! Drrrr! Did you hear that Mr Hat? I sure did Mr Garrison, what a retard!
HeHeHeHe...

I think you see where my allegiance lieth.

Although I do agree largely with a lot of the comments saying that he/she is there as a means to set up sex/sexuality jokes.
Which is OK isn't it?

[CobainIsMyBitch]

mr. garrison was way funnier than ms.

[Mike; Off-Duty Ninja]

Mr. Garrison was funnier. He was more crazy. Pretty soon Ms. Garrison will wind up being bi or a transvestite.

About Mr. Hat, his return would be cool. Perhaps there could be an episode about him finding a new host. Maybe like Cartman, who I eerily find similar to Garrison personality-wise. Or maybe Mr. Hat could find himself accompanying Darth Chef.

[CobainIsMyBitch]

Mr. Garrison was funnier. He was more crazy. Pretty soon Ms. Garrison will wind up being bi or a transvestite.

About Mr. Hat, his return would be cool. Perhaps there could be an episode about him finding a new host. Maybe like Cartman, who I eerily find similar to Garrison personality-wise. Or maybe Mr. Hat could find himself accompanying Darth Chef.

she did turn lesbian in "Dykes!"

[BRMBug]

Like I said, Garrison's gotten so gay he's circled back around to straight again.

[PIPaul]

Mr Garrison isn't gay and never has been, he's far too crazy to be gay. His sexual identity is constantly changing, because he needs to be even more extreme for himself, just like the show. The sex is just as much a manifestation of his madness as Hat or Twig.

I think his treatment of Mr. Slave was very in keeping with the charactar. He's a sociopath who doesn't really care about anyone else and expects them to do what he wants them to do on a whim, he's like an adult Cartman. I wouldn't be supprised if, Terminator Style, he was the future Cartman, except he's thin and has a female mum and all that.

That said, Garrison was never better than in his early days with Mr. Hat. We need the farther adventures of Mr. Hat